Debunking 15 Myths about the Amish

The Amish have long intrigued and mystified those outside their communities. Known for their simple lifestyle, Christian pacifism, and slowness in adopting modern technology, the Amish are often subjects of curiosity and misconceptions. Here, we debunk 15 false myths about the Amish that you must stop believing.

Amish Don’t Use Any Technology

While they are known for shunning modern conveniences, the Amish use some forms of technology. The extent to which technology is adopted varies among communities. For example, some Amish use battery-powered tools, generators, and cell phones for business purposes. The decision is often based on whether the technology will negatively impact their community and values.

Amish Don’t Pay Taxes

The Amish pay taxes, including property, income, and sales taxes. However, they are excused from Social Security taxes because they do not accept Social Security benefits and rely instead on their community for support in times of need.

Amish Don’t Accept Medical Care

Contrary to popular belief, the Amish do seek medical care when necessary. They prefer natural and home remedies but will visit doctors and hospitals for serious health issues. Many Amish communities have arrangements with local healthcare providers and hospitals.

Amish Education Stops at Eighth Grade

While it is true that Amish formal education typically ends at the eighth grade, education continues in the form of vocational training and hands-on learning. Amish children learn practical skills through apprenticeships and working alongside their parents.

Amish Don’t Allow Photography

The Amish are generally opposed to having their photographs taken, especially in ways considered prideful or vain. However, this does not mean they will aggressively prevent all photography. Respectful and discreet photography may be tolerated in some cases, particularly when faces are not shown.

Amish Marriages Are Arranged

Young Amish people choose their partners, often through social gatherings and church events. Courtship practices may be traditional, but the choice of spouse is ultimately personal.

Amish Don’t Interact With Outsiders

The community does interact with outsiders, especially in business. Many Amish run businesses that cater to non-Amish customers, such as furniture making, construction, and food markets. They also employ non-Amish individuals in some of their enterprises.

Amish Are All Farmers

While farming remains a significant aspect of Amish life, not all Amish are farmers. They are sometimes involved in various trades and crafts, such as woodworking, blacksmithing, and quilt-making. Entrepreneurship is common in Amish communities.

Amish Don’t Use Cars

Horse-and-buggy travel remains the backbone of daily transportation for the Amish.  For long distances or emergencies, they’ll hire drivers or use taxis, showing their openness to motor vehicles in certain situations.

Amish Don’t Use Electricity

The Amish typically do not connect to the public electrical grid. However, they do use alternative power sources like batteries, solar panels, and generators. These allow them to operate necessary equipment without compromising their values.

Amish Are Unfriendly to Outsiders

Reservedness can be a sign of respect in some cultures, and it can be misinterpreted as coldness. Valuing humility and modesty might come across as aloofness for the Amish.  However, a respectful approach can lead to friendly conversations and insights into their way of life.

Amish Don’t Have Modern Conveniences

Despite avoiding certain modern conveniences, the Amish have adopted many aspects of modern life. For example, they use propane-powered refrigerators, gas stoves, and battery-operated tools. Their lifestyle choices are more about community values than outright rejection of modernity.

Amish Are a Dying Culture

Their population is actually growing. High birth rates and a strong sense of community contribute to their growth. Some individuals do leave the Amish way of life. It also holds that the majority remain and continue to uphold their traditions.

Amish Life is Completely Isolated

The Amish live within broader American society and are not completely isolated. They engage in commerce, use public roads, and interact with non-Amish neighbors. Their communities are insular, just not cut off from the outside world.

Amish Don’t Engage in Modern Commerce

Businesses in the Amish community often engage in modern commerce, utilizing markets and customers from outside of their community. Limited technology use does define the Amish lifestyle, including the internet. Yet, they can still participate in the modern economy indirectly. Trusted outsiders might help sell their goods online or find needed supplies.