Grayson West
Mascara might seem like a small choice, but pick the right shade and your eye color suddenly does more. More contrast, more warmth, more glow you didn’t know you had. Sure, black works—but what if navy or plum gave your eyes an actual mood? These 10 shades aren’t just trends; they’re subtle power moves for your lashes. Let’s break them down by eye color, so you can swipe smarter.
Black Mascara
There’s a reason black mascara is a universal choice. It sharpens the lash line just enough to bring the eyes forward without adding noise. And because it stays in the background, it fits easily, whether you’re wearing a bare face or something more layered.
Brown Mascara
With brown mascara, the effect is subtler. Instead of building a sharp dimension, this shade leans into softness, especially on blue or green eyes. That shift gives the gaze room to settle, delivering a definition that enhances your eyes while preserving their natural shape.
Blue Mascara
Blue mascara can really brighten brown or gray eyes. The cool tone refines the lash line and makes the whites of the eyes stand out. Plus, it’s an easy way to add color with no need for eyeshadow. Just swipe and go for an instant lift!
Navy Mascara
Navy looks quiet in the tube, but when it hits green or hazel eyes, suddenly everything becomes more vivid. It’s neither loud like blue nor flat like black. Yet, it sharpens the edges enough to build a contrast that feels like something out of a painting.
Green Mascara
For brown and hazel eyes, green mascara is a flattering twist. It highlights those warm flecks, adds depth without going overboard, and works like a charm when you’re craving something fresh. Even better, it comes alive in softer lighting, where the color adds warmth subtly.
Burgundy Mascara
Burgundy mascara works beautifully on green and hazel eyes, as its red undertones warm the lash line and enhance golden or amber flecks in the iris. For best results, pair it with a neutral eye base and skip the liner so the color can carry the entire look on its own.
Purple Mascara
Too much? Maybe at first. But once it’s on, purple mascara softens blue eyes instantly, and adds just enough contrast to accentuate the gaze. Ultimately, what starts soft ends up landing with clarity and coolness that holds on just long enough to get noticed.
Teal mascara
When teal mascara comes through, brown eyes shift from warm to balanced. The pigment also clears out muddiness and adds definition in a single swipe. That’s why a neutral lid matters, since anything more could crowd the color and pull the focus away from the lashes.
Gray mascara
This one’s for the soft-glam queens. Gray mascara lets blue and gray eyes stay natural while still giving definition. It vibes best in soft light or on more mature skin, where it adds just the right amount of lift without turning the whole look loud.
Plum mascara
There’s already something interesting in green and hazel eyes, but plum mascara amps it up by warming the lash line and making soft flecks pop. And if you want an easy boost, pair it with copper or bronze shadow to echo the color.