The Best and Worst Things To Eat at Arby’s

Arby’s, known for its slogan “We Have the Meats,” offers a tasty menu that ranges from classic roast beef sandwiches to delicious chicken and other dishes. We have carefully curated a list of the best and worst menu items so you can navigate Arby’s menu more effectively and enjoy a more satisfying meal. Here’s a quick rundown of Arby’s top hits and misses.

The Best Items 

Classic Roast Beef Sandwich

Arby’s Classic Roast Beef Sandwich is a timeless favorite that keeps customers returning. It features juicy, thinly sliced roast beef on a toasted sesame seed bun—simple yet satisfying. For a simple, tasty breakfast or lunch option, it’s actually a top pick.

Curly Fries

Arby’s Curly Fries are a beloved side that complements any meal. These crispy, seasoned spirals are flavorful and provide an excellent crunch. They’re a fun and tasty alternative to regular fries, earning them a top spot on the best menu items list.

Beef ‘n Cheddar

The Beef’ n Cheddar, featuring savory roast beef, rich cheese sauce, and tangy red ranch sauce, is a definite crowd-pleaser. Served on a toasted onion roll, this sandwich gives you a burst of flavor in every bite, making it a must-try for anyone seeking to savor the finest that Arby’s offers.

Smokehouse Brisket Sandwich

The Smokehouse Brisket Sandwich stands out for its smoky, tender brisket paired with crispy onions, melted cheese, and barbecue sauce. The succulent flavor and texture create a satisfying meal. With 26 grams of protein and 600 calories, you will definitely get a rich and flavorful dining experience.

Loaded Italian Sandwich

Packed with layers of salami, pepperoni, ham, and melted cheese, topped with banana peppers and zesty Italian dressing, the Loaded Italian Sandwich is a flavor-packed delight. The dish shines with its fresh ingredients and bold flavors, which always make it a pleasing choice for Italian cuisine lovers.

Turkey Gyro

The Turkey Gyro combines tender turkey with a variety of fresh toppings, all wrapped in a soft pita. Adding tzatziki sauce adds a creamy, tangy element that enhances the overall taste. It is a lighter yet satisfying option for those seeking a healthier alternative.

Jamocha Shake

The Jamocha Shake is a beloved dessert drink that perfectly combines chocolate and coffee flavors. It is smooth and creamy and provides a delightful finish to any meal at Arby’s. Lovers of both chocolate and coffee find this shake irresistible.

Classic French Dip & Swiss

The Classic French Dip & Swiss is a hit with its thinly sliced roast beef and melted Swiss cheese plated on a toasted subroll. The au jus for dipping adds a savory touch, enhancing the flavor. Try this warm and comforting alternative whenever you crave a hearty meal.

Smoke Mountain Sandwich

The Smoke Mountain Sandwich is a towering combination of brisket, pork belly, and smoked turkey, all topped with crispy onions. This sandwich is a meat lover’s dream, delivering a smoky and savory feast in every bite. This robust option showcases Arby’s meat expertise on a very high level.

The Worst Items

Fish Sandwich

Arby’s Fish Sandwich often needs to catch up to the competition. Many customers find the fish to be overly breaded and lacking in flavor. Despite its crunchy exterior, the sandwich doesn’t offer the freshness or zest that seafood lovers expect, so you want to avoid it as much as possible. 

Arby-Q Sandwich

Many customers dislike the Arby-Q Sandwich because of its overly sweet barbecue sauce. The roast beef’s flavor combination doesn’t quite hit the mark. At 400 calories and 18 grams of sugar, it often leaves diners wishing for a more balanced flavor profile.

Ham and Swiss Melt

The Ham and Swiss Melt lacks the excitement found in other Arby’s offerings. Currently, the sandwich often comes across as a bit bland. They could do more on this one by switching it up and making it more flavorful.

Chicken Tenders

Arby’s Chicken Tenders are often criticized for being dry and lacking seasoning. While they might appeal to those seeking a simple meal, they don’t stand out among the chain’s more flavorful menu items, and many customers find them disappointing. 

Three Cheese Beef and Bacon

The Three Cheese Beef and Bacon sandwich isn’t as good as many of their customers would want it to be. It comes off as having an overly greasy texture. The combination of multiple cheeses and bacon often overwhelms the roast beef, leading to a heavy and unbalanced meal. Diners prefer Arby’s simpler and more refined sandwiches.

Market Fresh Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich

The Market Fresh Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich is of inconsistent quality, and many other food brands do a better job than Arby’s on this one. Some people find the chicken salad mixture too sweet and the bread choice too dense, making it a less appealing option. Other Arby’s sandwiches provide a more reliable and enjoyable experience.

Pizza Slider

The Pizza Slider, though intriguing, lacks an authentic pizza flavor. The ingredients fail to meld together in a way that satisfies pizza cravings. Customers looking for a slider option usually succeed more with Arby’s other offerings.